A good tenant's lease ends in four months. Two things can happen. They sign again, or they leave and you lease the unit to somebody else. Every operator knows the second one costs more. Very few have put a number on how much more, and the number matters because it sets the value of everything you might do in the next four months to make the first outcome more likely.
This is that arithmetic, run as two scenarios on one unit. It is deliberately not about what rent to ask. You have already decided that, or you will, using your own market data. The question here is narrower and more useful: at whatever rent you have settled on, what does a renewal cost you, what does a turn cost you, and how far apart are they?
The numbers that are published
Start with what can be sourced, because the temptation in this arithmetic is to make the turn look as expensive as possible, and the case does not need it.
Turnover and leasing cost. The National Apartment Association's 2024 Income/Expense IQ put leasing expenses at $292 per unit for 2024, up 4.6% on the year, and attributed that rise largely to a 17.5% year-over-year increase in turnover costs. It also put vacancy and rent loss at $1,323 per unit, up 2.6% and the fourth consecutive annual increase, within total operating expenses of $8,657 per unit. Read these as what they are: per-unit averages across a whole portfolio, occupied units included. The leasing figure is spread across every unit, not charged to the ones that turned. The cost of one actual turn is several times higher, and it is yours to measure.
Vacancy. The US Census Bureau put the national rental vacancy rate at 7.3% in the second quarter of 2026, against 7.0% a year earlier. A soft market means a turn takes longer to fill, and every day of that is covered in how much a vacant unit costs per day, which also explains why rent divided by thirty understates it.
Renewal rates. The National Apartment Association's operating survey put apartment turnover at 46.8% a year, the figure NAA still cites in its 2025 guidance on turnover; put the other way round, a little over half of residents stayed. The listed apartment owners publish their own numbers every quarter, and they sit higher. Equity Residential reported 60.0% of residents renewing in the second quarter of 2026, with occupancy and resident retention "at historically high levels". MAA reported resident turnover of 39.6% of expiring leases over the twelve months to June 2026, which it called historically low. Across those sources the picture is consistent: roughly half to three-fifths of expiring leases renew, and the best-run portfolios are at the top of that range.
Why tenants stay. Zillow's 2025 Consumer Housing Trends Report asked tenured renters what encouraged them to stay. The top answers were that their rental costs were a good deal (75%), quiet neighbors (71%) and not being able to afford to move elsewhere (69%). Among tenured renters who saw an increase over two years, the median was $130, about 12%. Price is in the answer, but so is the experience of living there, and that second part is yours regardless of what the first part is.
The unit
One unit, for both scenarios. The market figures above are published and sourced; the property inputs below are assumptions chosen to make the arithmetic legible, and yours will differ. Replace every one of them with your own before you act on any of this.
- A two-bedroom in a mid-size building, current rent $1,500 a month, lease ending in four months.
- The tenant has paid on time for two years and has never generated a maintenance call you would describe as avoidable.
- You have already settled, by whatever method you use, on the rent you will offer at renewal and the rent you would list at if the unit turned. For this exercise they are the same number, $1,500, so that the comparison isolates the cost of the turn itself. If your two numbers differ, the arithmetic below still holds; the difference between them is a separate line you add at the end.
Scenario A: renew at the current rent
The tenant signs another twelve-month lease at $1,500.
- Rent forgone: zero days vacant, so $0.
- Make-ready: nothing. Perhaps a maintenance visit you would have done anyway.
- Leasing labor: a renewal conversation, a lease document, two signatures. Call it two hours of a coordinator's time. At a loaded cost of $35 an hour, $70.
- Marketing: $0. The unit was never listed.
- Screening: $0. You already know who lives there. A tenant who has lived in the property without incident is better evidence than any records-based screen, a point HUD's 2024 screening guidance, since archived, had also made.
- Risk of the unknown: nil. You know exactly how this tenant pays and how they treat the unit.
Scenario A total: roughly $70. And the unit earns $1,500 in the month the lease would have ended, as it did every month before.
Scenario B: turn the unit
The tenant leaves at the end of the lease. You make the unit ready, list it, show it, screen applicants, sign a new lease at the same $1,500.
- Days vacant. Assume 25 days from move-out to the new lease start. That covers a week of make-ready and eighteen days to list, show, screen and sign, which in a 7.3% vacancy market is not pessimistic. Rent forgone at $1,500 ÷ 30 × 25 = $1,250.
- Make-ready. Paint, cleaning, carpet or floor repair, small fixes that accumulated over two years, one trade visit. Assume $1,400. NAA's 17.5% jump in turnover costs is the rate at which this line has been growing; your invoices from the last three turns give you the level.
- Leasing labor. Photographs, listing copy, posting to several channels, replying to inquiries, two or three showing trips, reading applications, preparing a lease. Assume twelve hours at the same $35, $420.
- Marketing. Listing fees on any paid channel, assume $60.
- Screening cost not recovered by the application fee. Time to process applications that do not result in a lease. Zillow's 2025 report found the typical recent renter submitted two applications, which means roughly half of the applications you process for this unit end in something other than a lease. Assume $50.
- Costs you pay only because the unit is empty. Utilities you pick up while nobody lives there, a lockbox, a cleaning visit before showings. Assume $50 for the 25 days. Property tax, insurance and financing are not on this list: you pay them whether the unit is let or not, and the rent forgone above already captures what the vacancy takes from you.
- Concession. In a market soft enough that concessions are back, assume half a month free to land the new tenant: $750. If your market does not require one, strike this line.
- Risk of the unknown. The new tenant is a stranger with a good application. Most work out. Some do not, and the cost when they do not is large and arrives later. No number is attached here because no honest one exists, but it is not zero and it sits entirely on this side.
Scenario B total: roughly $3,980, with the concession, or $3,230 without it.
The gap
At the same rent, the turn costs this unit somewhere between $3,160 and $3,910 more than the renewal. On a $1,500 unit that is between two and two and a half months of rent, spent to arrive at exactly the income you already had.
Put differently: the tenant who renews is worth between $3,160 and $3,910 to you in avoided cost before any question of rent arises. That figure is the budget for everything you might do in the next four months to keep them, and it is larger than most operators have in mind when deciding whether to return a call about a dripping faucet.
Now the two adjustments that make this yours.
If your renewal rent and your listing rent differ, the difference, times twelve, is a line you add to whichever scenario has the lower rent. That is the only place rent enters this arithmetic, and it enters as a number you supplied.
Across a portfolio, multiply by frequency. If a 120-unit firm sees 45% of expiring leases not renew, a little under the 46.8% turnover in NAA's survey, that is 54 turns a year. At the gap above, the difference between a firm that renews 55% and one that renews 65% is twelve turns, or between $38,000 and $47,000 a year, on a portfolio that did not change its rents at all. The published figures, a little over half renewing in NAA's survey against about three-fifths at the listed operators, suggest the spread between an average operator and a strong one is of that order.
What the gap does not tell you
Three cautions, because this arithmetic is easy to misuse.
It does not say renew everyone. A tenant who pays late, damages the unit or makes the building worse for the neighbors is not the tenant this article is about. The 71% of Zillow's tenured renters who cited quiet neighbors as a reason to stay are telling you that the wrong renewal has a cost too, paid by the tenants around it.
It does not say what rent to offer. That is your market, your comparables and your judgment. The gap tells you what a turn costs at whatever rent you choose. It does not tell you to trade rent for retention, and it does not tell you not to.
And it does not describe your unit until you replace the assumptions. The method is the deliverable; the figures are placeholders until your last three turns are in the spreadsheet.
The renewal conversation, on a timeline
The gap is decided long before the lease ends, and mostly by whether the conversation started on time. Here is the timeline that works for a twelve-month lease.
120 days out. Decide whether you want this tenant to renew. That is a real decision, made on payment history, condition of the unit and how they have been to live near. Settle the rent you will offer. Check the notice requirements in your lease and your jurisdiction, because several require a landlord to give notice of non-renewal or of a rent change a fixed number of days ahead, and the clock may already be running.
90 days out. Open the conversation. Not the offer, the conversation. A call or a visit that asks how the unit has been, whether anything needs fixing, and whether they are thinking about staying. Fix what they mention. A tenant deciding whether to stay is weighing exactly the things Zillow's respondents named: whether the deal feels fair and whether the place is pleasant to live in. Ninety days out, both are still yours to influence.
60 days out. Make the written offer. Rent, term, any changes to the lease, and a date by which you need an answer, set so that if the answer is no you still have time to market the unit before it empties. This is also the last comfortable moment to offer a choice of terms.
30 days out. If they have signed, confirm it in writing and stop. If they have not answered, ask once more, directly, and take the answer. If the answer is no, you have 30 days of paid occupancy in which to photograph the unit, list it and show it to pre-screened applicants before a single day of vacancy is incurred. Every one of those days is a day of the 25 in Scenario B that you did not have to pay for.
Move-out, if it comes to that. Walk the unit with the tenant, agree on the condition, return the deposit on the schedule your jurisdiction sets, and ask what would have kept them. The answer is data for the next 120-day decision, and it is free.
Run this timeline on every expiring lease and two things change. The share that renew goes up, because the tenants who were going to leave over a fixable irritation had it fixed at 90 days. And the turns that still happen get cheaper, because the marketing started at 60 and the showings at 30, while the rent was still coming in. Operators forget that second effect, and it is worth nearly as much as the first.